Showing posts with label Bobby Bowden. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bobby Bowden. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 1, 2009

On Bowden vs. Paterno: The Final Verdict


I will submit my usual disclaimer up front: I have a deep and inherent bias on this issue.

So this is how it ends for Bobby Bowden. It's a bit protracted, a bit painful, as these things tend to be, though it's not quite as bad as it could have been--at least it's not a Woody Hayes ending. And let me say this: I'll miss the guy, even if I never had any real affinity for his football teams. I'll miss his dadgums, and I'll miss his charm, and I'll miss that squinty look of his, which always made him appear as if he'd left his bifocals in the locker room. As a football coach, it felt like Bowden was perpetually underestimated, perhaps because he was so charming, skillful at deflecting credit in the wake of victory and shouldering blame in the face of defeat--and no one suffered more painful defeats than Bowden's teams in the 1990's. He was one of the game's most earnest ambassadors, and he was an epically successful football coach, and even when he was angry he was charming.

But he is nowhere near the coach Joe Paterno is.

Now, I doubt these men ever meant to set themselves up for a direct comparison. It just kind of happened, as they both refused to succumb to age, as their victory totals soared past three hundred, past three fifty, past Warner and Stagg and the Bear. In Paterno's autobiography, written in 1989, there is not a single mention of Bowden in the index. (There are ten mentions of Bear Bryant.) They were always friendly, but they had separate objectives. Bowden never seemed interested in being much more than a successful football coach. This was his prerogative; this was what mattered to him, and there is no shame in that, but Paterno never framed his occupation that way. Call him self-righteous, call him self-aggrandizing, but--with the exception of Bear Bryant, who happened to come along at a moment of radical change in the American south, and perhaps Eddie Robinson--Paterno did more to change the perception of an entire university than any coach in the history of the game. Penn State is a completely different college than it was when my father arrived there as a professor in 1978--it's far better than it was when I graduated fifteen (gulp) years ago--and while it's still not Yale (or even Swarthmore), you have to give some of this credit to Paterno, who, for all his faults, has always focused on the reputation of the university as a whole. Because of Paterno, Penn State has elevated its stature as an academic institution, and this is a unique legacy, and this is something that cannot be duplicated, and this is why the victory numbers don't matter. This is why they never mattered.

In terms of one's ability to recruit/coach winning football teams, you may argue all you like. But in terms of legacy, it's not even close.  

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

On Bowden v. Paterno

There's a great quote toward the end of Michael O'Brien's biography of Joe Paterno, No Ordinary Joe. It's from Jim Tarman, the former athletic director at Penn State, one of the hundreds of prominent central Pennyslvania figures that Joe has managed to outlast at the school. Tarman talks about Paterno's vitality, about his seeming inability to age, about how, at sixty-five, he came across as a forty-five year old. "I've never been around anyone who has aged as reluctantly as Joe," Tarman says, and that word--reluctance--just about says it all. The man refuses to resign himself to obsolescence, for better or worse. I kind of think his plan all along was to keep on going until his body or his mind broke down completely (there was never a five-year retirement plan, despite his hundreds of declarations to the contrary), but I also believe there's a factor lurking in the background that has kept him going, and that's this back-and-forth with Bobby Bowden for the all-time Division I-A wins record. In fact, I've got to believe it's kept them both going, no matter what they might say, no matter their declarations of friendship, or their insistence upon the irrelevance of numbers. Among competitive people, it has to matter. To think otherwise would be naive, wouldn't it?

Still, I don't feel particularly good about what's happening to Bowden at the moment. It feels ineluctably familiar: An aging coach under siege, called upon to resign, struggling to survive the season. For all his flaws, Bowden always seemed like a genial (though sometimes discomfiting--witness his half-joking dismissal of the reporter in the linked clip above as acting, "like a woman") human who deserves credit for establishing one of the most iconic programs in college football history. Both men have had suffered through inevitable declines this decade; only Paterno has recovered (at least for now). Maybe Joe just found a more effective way to delegate responsibility. Or maybe Bowden is just aging more severely. Or maybe Bowden is at a competitive disadvantage in a state with so much viable competition for recruits, whereas Paterno has a more established base in the Northeast. It's hard to know, but it just doesn't seem like it's going end well for at least one of them, and I have to imagine the chase for the victories record has far more to do with this than either man would admit--but especially Bowden, who never appeared as obsessive or high-strung or defiant, who almost seems to be clinging rather than coaching at this point.

It's kind of interesting to wonder how it might affect Paterno if Bowden resigns after this season; maybe it would provide both men with a sense of relief, a reason to let go before the end comes. Maybe Bowden's retirement is the best thing that could happen for both of them. You can age as reluctantly as you want, but eventually, gravity is going to catch up with all of us.

(Photo: Al Bello/Getty Images)